A cushion halo diamond engagement ring in rose gold worn on a finger

Your jewelry is worth more than you think

Gold buyers in NYC, on Madison Avenue in Midtown Manhattan

Honest appraisals. Transparent pricing. Top dollar paid for gold, luxury watches, diamonds and fine jewelry.

A jewelry showroom with long glass display counters, tall black stools and a round lit ceiling

Choose Manhattan gold buyers who pay more

With over 15 years in the business, Madison Ave Gold Buyers has built a reputation for honest service, transparent pricing and exceptional value. We buy gold, jewelry, diamonds, luxury watches and other precious metals through a straightforward, no-pressure process designed to get you the most for your pieces.

Every item is evaluated by experienced buyers, and because we buy directly, you receive competitive offers without unnecessary middlemen. Visit our Madison Avenue showroom in Midtown Manhattan for a free appraisal and see the confidence that comes from working with a trusted local buyer.

What we buy

Get more with our cash for gold services

Our cash for gold process is straightforward, transparent and rewarding. Whether you are selling broken gold, unwanted jewelry, coins or other precious metals, we give you a professional evaluation and explain each step. We test and weigh your items in front of you, offer competitive pricing, and never pressure you to sell. Visit our Madison Avenue showroom for a free appraisal and find out how much your gold is worth.

We also buy: cash for gold, everyday and vintage watches.

A rose gold Rolex Daytona and a rose gold Rolex Day-Date held side by side in an open hand

Gold buyers setting the standard since 2010

Since 2010, our business has earned a reputation for professionalism, integrity and personal service throughout New York City. Every client receives one-on-one attention from experienced buyers who take the time to evaluate each item carefully and answer every question honestly. Whether you are selling a single piece or an entire collection, we make the experience comfortable, confidential and straightforward.

  • Free appraisals, with no obligation to sell
  • Tested and weighed in front of you
  • Top-dollar offers, paid in cash

Find out why so many clients come back to us and recommend us to family and friends. Read more about us.

Luxury watch buyers who appreciate craftsmanship

Selling a luxury timepiece is about more than its value. It is about working with people who recognize the craftsmanship, history and precision behind every watch. We evaluate each piece on its brand, condition, rarity and current market demand to make a fair and competitive offer. Whether you are selling a contemporary luxury watch or a collectible heirloom, you can expect a private, transparent, no-pressure experience from beginning to end.

Gold coin buyers and antique jewelry buyers offering honest evaluations

Whether you are selling collectible gold coins or cherished antique jewelry, you deserve an evaluation that is honest, transparent and backed by experience. We assess each piece on authenticity, rarity, condition, historical significance and current market demand to make a fair and competitive offer.

From family heirlooms to valuable coin collections, every item is handled with professionalism and respect. Visit Madison Ave Gold Buyers for a free, no-obligation evaluation and learn the true value of your pieces.

A yellow gold screw-motif bangle held up over a blue cloth

Estate jewelry buyers treating every heirloom with care

Whether you are settling an estate, downsizing a collection or parting with a cherished family heirloom, our estate jewelry buyers give thoughtful, professional evaluations in a respectful, no-pressure setting. We carefully assess vintage, antique and modern jewelry so every piece is valued for its craftsmanship, condition and market demand, helping you make informed decisions with confidence.

  • Vintage jewelry
  • Antique estate pieces
  • Modern fine jewelry

Let us help you learn the value of your treasured pieces with a free, no-pressure evaluation.

15+ years of five-star service

For more than 15 years, we have built lasting relationships through honest evaluations, transparent pricing and exceptional customer service. We take pride in creating a comfortable, no-pressure experience where every client is treated with professionalism and respect. Read what our clients have to say, then visit us for a free appraisal and experience the difference for yourself.

  • All reviews 4.7
  • Google 5.0
  • Yelp 5.0
  • Facebook 3.5

Overall rating 4.7 (36 reviews)

  • Max PragaGoogle review

    Highly recommend! Responsive, reliable, and excellent execution from start to finish.

  • Yumi KarmelGoogle review

    When buying custom jewelry, Josh is the man you wanna see! He helped us through the process, and delivered a masterpiece! He answerd all our questions, and took care of all our concerns.

  • Joshua StephensGoogle review

    Best around. 10/10 on knowledge and honesty AND highest offer I received on my goods.

A diamond solitaire engagement ring standing in an open black ring boxA diamond halo ring with an emerald cut center stone in a white and red ring boxDiamond rings, a diamond pendant and a diamond tennis bracelet on black velvet

Engagement ring and diamond buyers who understand every stone

Whether you are selling a diamond engagement ring, a loose diamond or fine diamond jewelry, we evaluate every stone with precision and care. We carefully assess cut, color, clarity, carat weight, craftsmanship and current market demand to make a fair and competitive offer.

From cherished engagement rings to investment-quality diamonds, every piece is handled with professionalism, discretion and complete transparency. Visit Madison Ave Gold Buyers for a free, no-obligation evaluation and learn the true value of your diamond.

How it works

What happens when you bring something in

  1. Bring it in, or call first

    Walk into our showroom during opening hours, or call ahead if you would rather set a time or ask what to bring. There is no charge to have something looked at, and no obligation once you are here.

  2. We test and weigh it in front of you

    Gold is tested for karat and weighed in front of you. Diamonds and colored stones are read under the loupe, and a watch is checked by model, reference and condition. You watch every step and can ask what each one means.

  3. You get a clear offer and the reason for it

    We explain what we found and make an offer, and we tell you what drove it: the weight and purity for gold, the 4Cs for a diamond, the model and condition for a watch. If you want time to think or to compare, that is fine.

  4. Say yes and get paid in cash

    Accept the offer and we pay you in cash before you leave. If you would rather not sell, you take your pieces home. Nothing is bought until you agree to the price.

Selling guide

How selling gold, diamonds and watches works

Six short guides to what happens at our counter and what sets the price of what you bring in. Open any one to read it.

At the counter

How a sale works at our Madison Avenue counter

Most people who sell to us have never done it before, so here is exactly what happens, with nothing hidden. You bring your gold, jewelry, coins or watch to our Madison Avenue showroom in Midtown Manhattan. You do not need an appointment, though you can call first if you want to set a time or check what to bring for a particular item.

Everything is examined in front of you. We do not take your pieces into a back room. Gold is tested for its karat and placed on a scale you can see, diamonds and colored stones are read under a loupe, and a watch is checked against its model and reference. As we go, we explain what we are looking at and why it matters, so the offer at the end is not a mystery number.

The offer, and your choice

When the testing is done we make an offer and tell you how we reached it. For gold that is the weight and purity against the day’s price. For a diamond it is the 4Cs. For a watch it is the model, the condition and whether you have the box and papers. You are free to take the offer, think about it, or walk out with everything you came in with. We would rather lose a sale than pressure anyone into one.

If you accept, you are paid in cash on the spot. We buy directly from you, with no middleman taking a cut and nothing mailed away to be assessed somewhere else. New York City rules require any buyer of second-hand jewelry to record each purchase and to hold items for a set period before reselling, which is there to protect honest sellers. Our FAQs page explains what to bring, how payment works and what identification you need.

If you have a mix of things, a drawer of odd gold, a few coins, an old ring and a watch, bring all of it. We sort and value each piece on its own, and you can sell some and keep the rest. Not sure what you have? Start with our jewelry buyers page and we will point you to the right place.

Bring your pieces to our showroom for a free appraisal, with no pressure to sell.

Why us

Why sell with a Madison Avenue buyer

Our showroom sits on Madison Avenue, right in Midtown Manhattan, and we have bought gold, diamonds, jewelry, coins and watches directly from the public there for over 15 years. That matters to you in a simple way. You are selling to the buyer, not to a middleman who will turn around and sell your piece to someone like us. Cutting out those extra hands is how a direct buyer can pay more and pay faster.

Fifteen years of buying from walk-in sellers means we have handled a lot of what comes across the counter, from a single worn chain to a mixed estate, a loose diamond or a boxed luxury watch. That range is why you can bring everything to one place, rather than hoping one shop happens to know watches as well as it knows gold.

Everything is tested and weighed in front of you, and we explain what we see as we go, so the offer at the end is not a mystery number. The appraisal is free and there is never any pressure to sell. You are welcome to take the offer, think it over, or walk out with everything you came in with. We would rather you sold to us feeling sure than felt rushed into it.

Buying directly, not through a chain

We buy directly from the public. A mail-in service or a suburban shop usually has to send your gold or stone on to a buyer anyway, and every hand it passes through takes a margin out of what you get. When you sell to us in person, you skip all of that and keep your property in your sight until you agree to a price.

Midtown Manhattan is easy to reach by train or on foot, so coming in is one short trip. When you are ready, our about page explains who we are and how long we have worked here, and our contact page has our hours and directions.

Visit our Madison Avenue showroom in Midtown Manhattan and see the offer in person.

Selling gold

What sets the price when you sell gold

Two things decide what your gold is worth: how much gold is in it, and how much gold is selling for on the day you come in. Everything else is noise. Jewelry is almost never pure gold, because pure gold is soft, so it is mixed with other metals and stamped with a karat mark. Pure gold is 24 karat. An 18 karat piece is 75 percent gold, 14 karat is about 58 percent, and 10 karat, the lowest that can be sold as gold in the United States, is about 42 percent.

We test each piece to confirm the karat rather than trusting the stamp alone, then weigh it. Precious metals are weighed in troy ounces, and a troy ounce divides into twenty pennyweights, so if you see the scale reading in pennyweights that is the jeweler’s measure, not an attempt to confuse you. Weight and purity together give the amount of actual gold in your piece.

The day’s price

That amount of gold is then valued against the current market price, which is quoted per troy ounce and moves every day. The LBMA publishes a widely used benchmark you can check before you come in, so you have a reference point for what raw gold is worth that day. A fair offer for scrap or broken gold tracks that price, less the cost of refining.

Coins are a little different. A gold coin can be worth its metal, or more than its metal if collectors want it, so coins are handled on our gold coin buyers page. For chains, charms, broken pieces and dental gold, our gold buyers page covers how we test and weigh, and our cash for gold page walks through getting paid before you leave.

Check the day’s gold price, then bring your gold in for a free, no pressure appraisal.

Selling diamonds

What a diamond is actually worth

A diamond is not priced by size alone. The trade values every stone on four things, known as the 4Cs: color, clarity, cut and carat weight. Carat is weight, not size, so two stones that look similar across a table can be worth very different amounts. Color is graded on a scale from colorless down to faint yellow, clarity is about the tiny marks inside and on the surface, and cut is how well the stone was shaped to return light, which is what makes a diamond look alive.

When you bring a diamond in, we read it under the loupe on those four points, in front of you, and explain what we see. If your stone has a grading report we take that into account, and if it does not, we assess it here. You can read more about the four points on the GIA site, the independent institute that defined the 4Cs and grades diamonds without buying or selling them.

Several small round brilliant diamonds magnified inside a jeweler's loupe held in fingertips
A loose diamond held in tweezers under a loupe

Loose stones, jewelry and rings

A loose diamond is valued on its own merits. A diamond set in a ring or a pendant is valued on the stone plus the metal it sits in, and sometimes on the maker if it is a signed piece. Either way we separate the parts, so you can see where the figure comes from rather than being handed one lump sum.

If you are selling a diamond or diamond jewelry, our diamond buyers page goes deeper on how we assess a stone. If it is an engagement ring, after a divorce, an upgrade or an inheritance, our engagement ring buyers page is written for that. Older and period pieces are covered on our antique jewelry buyers page.

Bring your diamond or ring in and we will read it with you under the loupe.

Selling watches

What a luxury watch brings, and what lowers it

A watch is the one thing people most often undervalue when they sell, because its worth has little to do with the gold in it. For a luxury watch, the brand and the exact model drive the figure. The first things we need are the model and reference number and the serial number, which identify precisely which watch you have and which market it sits in. A Rolex Submariner and a Rolex Datejust are not interchangeable, and two versions of the same model can be worth very different amounts.

After the model, condition and completeness decide the rest. Scratches on the crystal, a worn bracelet, deep nicks and a faded dial all pull the offer down, while a clean, well kept piece brings more. Having the original box and papers, the purchase receipt and any service records lifts the value, because they prove the watch is genuine and show its history. None of these are required to sell, but they help.

A close view of a watch dial with gold hands and numerals on a dark navy face
The dial and bezel of a luxury watch, close up

Luxury brands and everyday watches

We buy Rolex, Patek Philippe, Cartier, Omega, Audemars Piguet and other high-end names, and these are covered on our luxury watch buyers page. A watch that is not a luxury brand still has value, as a running timepiece or for the gold in its case, and that is covered on our watch buyers page, so the right searcher lands in the right place.

Bring the watch, and the box and papers if you have them. We check it in front of you, explain what we see on the model and the condition, and make an offer you are free to take or leave.

Bring your watch, with its box and papers if you have them, for a free appraisal.

In person

Paid in person today, or an envelope in the mail

There are two ways to sell gold and jewelry: hand it to a buyer who tests it in front of you and pays you on the spot, or seal it in an envelope, mail it to a company you cannot see, and wait for whatever check they decide to send. The difference is not small.

When you sell in person, you watch the testing and the weighing, you hear how the offer was reached, and you can ask questions or walk away with your pieces still in your hand. You are paid cash on the spot. Nothing leaves your sight until you have agreed to a price. If the offer is not what you hoped, you have lost nothing but the trip.

What mail-in costs you

A mail-in kit asks you to give up all of that. Your gold is out of your hands and in the postal system before anyone has made an offer. The valuation happens where you cannot see it, on a scale you did not watch, and the first number you hear is often the last. Sending it back if you disagree means more time and more risk. The company still has to be paid, so whatever margin a middleman takes comes out of your check.

Coming into our Madison Avenue showroom is one short trip, and it keeps you in control of your own property the whole way through. If you cannot get in easily, call us first to talk it through. Our contact page has our hours and how to reach us, and our what sets us apart page is there as we gather feedback from the people we buy from.

Skip the envelope. Bring your gold and jewelry in and leave with cash that same visit.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Our most common questions are answered below.

What do you buy?

We buy gold in any form, from scrap and broken pieces to chains and dental gold, along with gold coins, loose diamonds and diamond jewelry, engagement rings, estate and antique jewelry, and watches from luxury brands down to everyday pieces. If you are not sure whether we buy what you have, our jewelry buyers page is a good place to start.

Do I need an appointment?

No. You are welcome to walk into our showroom during opening hours. If you would rather set a time, or ask what to bring for a particular item, call first. Our contact page has our hours.

Is the appraisal really free?

Yes. There is no charge to have your gold, jewelry, coins or watch examined and valued, and no obligation to sell afterward. If you do not like the offer, you take your pieces home.

How and when do I get paid?

If you accept an offer, you are paid in cash on the spot, at the counter. We buy directly from you, so there is no waiting for a check in the mail. Our cash for gold page explains payment in more detail.

How do you decide what my gold is worth?

Your gold is tested for its karat and weighed in front of you, then valued against the day’s market price per troy ounce. Weight and purity together give the amount of actual gold, and the offer tracks the current price, less refining. Our gold buyers page goes through it step by step.

How is a diamond valued?

On the 4Cs: color, clarity, cut and carat weight. We read the stone under the loupe in front of you and explain each point. A loose diamond is valued on its own, and a set stone is valued along with its metal. Our diamond buyers page has the detail.

What should I bring to sell a watch?

Bring the watch itself, and the original box and papers, the receipt and any service records if you have them, since they help prove it is genuine and lift the value. They are not required to sell. See our luxury watch buyers page for high-end brands.

Do I have to sell everything I bring?

No. We value each piece on its own, so you can sell some items and keep the rest. There is no pressure to sell the whole lot, which matters most with inherited pieces. Our estate jewelry buyers page is written for mixed lots.

Can I compare your offer with other buyers?

Yes, and we encourage it. There are plenty of buyers across Midtown Manhattan within a short distance, so you are free to shop the offer and come back. We would rather you sold to us feeling sure than felt rushed.

Where are you located?

On Madison Avenue in Midtown Manhattan. Use the call button to reach us, or tap through to our contact page for hours and directions.

Start your evaluation today

Fill out the form below and a member of our team will reach out as soon as possible. Or bring your items to the showroom for a free appraisal.

A steel Rolex Sky-Dweller with a blue dial and fluted bezel worn on a wrist
Call UsFree appraisal